Great review, nicely done!

The "ballad slot" has gotten a lot of attention this year, becoming a consistent feature in almost every 2012 setlist and seemingly part of a set "flow" that the band is working towards perfecting, with several unique choices ("If I Could," "Billy Breathes" etc) so far. I'm looking forward to further developments.

I agree with others about "Show of Life" too, though I understand where the reviewer is coming from. For me its one of the least cringe-worthy of a recent batch of sentimental/nostalgic songs, and it seems sincere to me, especially in the moment. Phish is certainly entitled to an occasionally overt gesture like that, it seems to me.