SET 1: Loving Cup > Maze, Martian Monster > Divided Sky > Prince Caspian -> NICU > Steam, Drift While You're Sleeping
SET 2: Set Your Soul Free, Tweezer -> Guy Forget -> Tweezer > What's the Use? > Scents and Subtle Sounds -> Tweezer -> Everything's Right > Backwards Down the Number Line > Tweezer Reprise
ENCORE: Harry Hood
Trey teased The Secret of Life (The Dead Milkmen) in Divided Sky. In NICU, Trey asked Page to "Play it slowly for us, Leo!" Guy Forget was played for the first time since September 4, 2011 (425 shows). The second Tweezer included a Frankenstein tease from Trey. Everything's Right had quotes of Manteca by Fish and teases of Tweezer from Trey, Page, and Fish.
 
			Photo by RJ Bee
 Sigma Oasis
					2
					Sigma Oasis
					2
					 A Picture of Nectar
					2
					A Picture of Nectar
					2
					 Joy
					1
					Joy
					1
					 Undermind
					1
					Undermind
					1
					 The Siket Disc
					1
					The Siket Disc
					1
					 Billy Breathes
					1
					Billy Breathes
					1
					 Stash
					1
					Stash
					1
					 Rift
					1
					Rift
					1
					 Junta
					1
					Junta
					1
					 The White Tape
					1
					The White Tape
					1
					 Holy shit my mind was completely blown tonight!!! I’ve been to over 300 shows and I was left totally speechless. What an incredible show. From start to finish it felt perfect. The band was so locked in and msg was on fucking fire tonight. I honestly can’t put it into words. WOW. WOW. WOW. I love you so much Phish!!!!!!
		Holy shit my mind was completely blown tonight!!! I’ve been to over 300 shows and I was left totally speechless. What an incredible show. From start to finish it felt perfect. The band was so locked in and msg was on fucking fire tonight. I honestly can’t put it into words. WOW. WOW. WOW. I love you so much Phish!!!!!!
	 I am gonna get critical, like it or not. Feel free to thumbs down and dislike, but I’ve always been a firm believer in sharing constructive feedback as opposed to gladhanding mediocrity.
		I am gonna get critical, like it or not. Feel free to thumbs down and dislike, but I’ve always been a firm believer in sharing constructive feedback as opposed to gladhanding mediocrity.  We can feel very good about being in this hood. Long time reader of reviews on here. Long time receiver of the email requesting to review a show. Finally coming around to giving it a try. Attending 7 shows in 9 days, I'd say is the perfect amount and frequency. I am tired, but not exhausted. My throat is sore, but seemingly not from wook flu. I get into my seat mere minutes before the show starts after what seems like the most challenging night getting into the venue and the lights go out to begin everyone's most common seen encore song—and a phenomenal one at that, especially in the opener slot of this encore night of the run. Loving Cup is always a pleaser, though I must say the only beautiful buzz I'm feeling at this stage of the evening is of my belly relieved at the bathroom break I had to take during the song. Which is a shame because the Maze Page solo is one of my favorites, but alas I'm back in my seat by the start of Trey's solo and as standard and well played as it is, the peak is always a nice Phish moment.
		We can feel very good about being in this hood. Long time reader of reviews on here. Long time receiver of the email requesting to review a show. Finally coming around to giving it a try. Attending 7 shows in 9 days, I'd say is the perfect amount and frequency. I am tired, but not exhausted. My throat is sore, but seemingly not from wook flu. I get into my seat mere minutes before the show starts after what seems like the most challenging night getting into the venue and the lights go out to begin everyone's most common seen encore song—and a phenomenal one at that, especially in the opener slot of this encore night of the run. Loving Cup is always a pleaser, though I must say the only beautiful buzz I'm feeling at this stage of the evening is of my belly relieved at the bathroom break I had to take during the song. Which is a shame because the Maze Page solo is one of my favorites, but alas I'm back in my seat by the start of Trey's solo and as standard and well played as it is, the peak is always a nice Phish moment.  What a complete and utter joy; a celebration of this band and this city and these seven shows. This was a culmination of the entire run, and will always be one of my favorite memories of this summer.
		What a complete and utter joy; a celebration of this band and this city and these seven shows. This was a culmination of the entire run, and will always be one of my favorite memories of this summer.  Was expecting something a bit more in line with 8-6-17. Always a fun time on Phish’s home court, but not a ton of memorable moments in this show outside of Tweezer (including Guy Forget!) > WTU. Got pretty excited for Scents, but that was aborted quickly for Everything’s Right/BDTNL, which were weird choices in what should have been a triumphant back half of the second set. I’m fine with Everything’s Right in the Set 2 opening slot, but having both Everything’s Right and SYSF in the set felt redundant, and I’m never going to get excited for a second set BDTNL.
		Was expecting something a bit more in line with 8-6-17. Always a fun time on Phish’s home court, but not a ton of memorable moments in this show outside of Tweezer (including Guy Forget!) > WTU. Got pretty excited for Scents, but that was aborted quickly for Everything’s Right/BDTNL, which were weird choices in what should have been a triumphant back half of the second set. I’m fine with Everything’s Right in the Set 2 opening slot, but having both Everything’s Right and SYSF in the set felt redundant, and I’m never going to get excited for a second set BDTNL.  I don't normally write reviews, but I felt like I needed to after that incredible summer tour. What an opening sequence with Loving Cup, Maze, Martian Monster, and a really good MM at that. Strayed from the normal. Then came Divided Sky and I thought about the faces and friends that I recall, the memories from Syracuse and 4 stunning MSG shows and how much joy this band brings every year, and started to get a little teary. To me, the band couldn't play a wrong note tonight.
		I don't normally write reviews, but I felt like I needed to after that incredible summer tour. What an opening sequence with Loving Cup, Maze, Martian Monster, and a really good MM at that. Strayed from the normal. Then came Divided Sky and I thought about the faces and friends that I recall, the memories from Syracuse and 4 stunning MSG shows and how much joy this band brings every year, and started to get a little teary. To me, the band couldn't play a wrong note tonight. Bliss and subliminal balance were the Themes of the night at yet another Barn Burner MSG show. The Boys were on a revenge tour and were taking no prisoners this time.
		Bliss and subliminal balance were the Themes of the night at yet another Barn Burner MSG show. The Boys were on a revenge tour and were taking no prisoners this time.  As always, these are all my own personal opinions. Never take reviews as fact!
		As always, these are all my own personal opinions. Never take reviews as fact! The second set of this show was one of the very best I've even seen in 31 years and 67 shows at MSG. Numberline was a bit of a buzzkill but if they play it, I dance! I saw 5 of the 7 shows in 9 days and a Medeski show in between near home. What an amazing week for live music! I saw the last Guy Forget at Dick's and picked it up right away. SaSS is a personal favorite and good set placement. I'm not always a huge WTU fan but this one was perfect. This was possibly the best MSG show I've seen since 12/30/97. Five stars!
		The second set of this show was one of the very best I've even seen in 31 years and 67 shows at MSG. Numberline was a bit of a buzzkill but if they play it, I dance! I saw 5 of the 7 shows in 9 days and a Medeski show in between near home. What an amazing week for live music! I saw the last Guy Forget at Dick's and picked it up right away. SaSS is a personal favorite and good set placement. I'm not always a huge WTU fan but this one was perfect. This was possibly the best MSG show I've seen since 12/30/97. Five stars!
	 This was my 67th Phish show at MSG. The second set might have been my favorite set there ever, with the exception of the over-celebrated 'Number Line'. The Tweezer Reprise set closer and Hood encore were just about perfect. I saw 5 of the 7 shows and this was my favorite, although 8/2 was metal AF and I liked that one too. I hope Phish gets to play MSG for years to come and the renovations to Penn Station to not involve further renovations to The Garden, my Home for Phish.
		This was my 67th Phish show at MSG. The second set might have been my favorite set there ever, with the exception of the over-celebrated 'Number Line'. The Tweezer Reprise set closer and Hood encore were just about perfect. I saw 5 of the 7 shows and this was my favorite, although 8/2 was metal AF and I liked that one too. I hope Phish gets to play MSG for years to come and the renovations to Penn Station to not involve further renovations to The Garden, my Home for Phish.
	 I usually rattle off my initial impressions on reviews, but this time I gave it a day and another listen and this is what I got.
		I usually rattle off my initial impressions on reviews, but this time I gave it a day and another listen and this is what I got. This is actually a Manteca Fest in conjunction with a Tweezer Fest. Surprised nobody noticed.
		This is actually a Manteca Fest in conjunction with a Tweezer Fest. Surprised nobody noticed. Loving Cup: Awesome! What a choice for an opener. Been a while since this happened, 6.24.04 to be exact at Deer Creek. This smokes.  >
		Loving Cup: Awesome! What a choice for an opener. Been a while since this happened, 6.24.04 to be exact at Deer Creek. This smokes.  > Add a Review
 Phish.net
Phish.netPhish.net is a non-commercial project run by Phish fans and for Phish fans under the auspices of the all-volunteer, non-profit Mockingbird Foundation.
This project serves to compile, preserve, and protect encyclopedic information about Phish and their music.
Credits | Terms Of Use | Legal | DMCA
 The Mockingbird Foundation
The Mockingbird FoundationThe Mockingbird Foundation is a non-profit organization founded by Phish fans in 1996 to generate charitable proceeds from the Phish community.
And since we're entirely volunteer – with no office, salaries, or paid staff – administrative costs are less than 2% of revenues! So far, we've distributed over $2 million to support music education for children – hundreds of grants in all 50 states, with more on the way.
Review by wearevotingyes
Thank you Phish, thank you Madison Square Garden, thank you New York, and thank you fans: these nine days will be ones we will tell stories about. We will ask, were you there and do you remember when?
Maze. Caspian. Divided Sky. Tweezer. Divided Sky. Everything’s Right. Harry Hood.
As good as it gets and better than should be expected for a band 40 years in.